Sisvel v ZTE, Tribunale Civile e Penale di Torino, Sezione I Civile

2016年03月4日 - 案号: 2695/2016 R.G.

http://caselaw.4ipcouncil.com/cn/italian-court-decisions/sisvel-v-zte-tribunale-civile-e-penale-di-torino-sezione-i-civile

Additional information: Sezione I Civile, specializzata in materia di impresa (specialized in enterprise issues).

1. Facts
   The proceedings before the Tribunale Civile e Penale di Torino concerned the appeal of Claimant in Case No. 30308/20215 R.G. seeking to set aside the decision of the court of first instance. As to the facts of the case, it can be referred to the summary of that case above.
2. Court’s reasoning
   Due to non-compliance with the minimum duration of the NDA, including apactum de non petendo in connection to ZTE Corporation and its affiliates (such as Defendant I), of three years until 3 September 2016, Claimant’s unilateral termination of the agreement by letter as of 13 October 2014 and the subsequent initiation of proceedings were declared inadmissible. Claimant validly waived its right to bring actions under Italian law and it cannot circumvent this obligation by paying damages. According to the wording of the agreement, a lack of reaction on the part of ZTE Corporation was not to be interpreted as a waiver of rights.
3. Other important issues
   Claimant argued that the patents in question never were essential to the UMTS standard and, hence, there existed no FRAND licensing obligation. The court rejected the appeal because Claimant’s action before the court of first instance was based on exactly the opposite argumentation (i.e. the patents in question being essential to the UMTS standard).