4iP Council Logo

案例法摘要

探索欧洲各国涉及 FRAND 许可和标准必要专利 (SEP) 的重要法院判决的简明摘要。

本文集从 2015 年欧盟法院作出具有里程碑意义的华为诉中兴通讯案判决后的裁决开始，该判决为 SEP 持有人和实施者应如何进行许可谈判制定了框架。

无论您是法律从业者、政策制定者、研究人员，还是商业利益相关者，本资源都旨在为您提供实用且不断发展的欧洲 FRAND 相关判例概览。


未引用案例？
让我们知道！
Title Country Court Case Number
华为诉Netgear，统一专利法院-慕尼黑地方分庭 华为诉Netgear统一专利法院-慕尼黑地方分庭 Unified Patent Court all unifiedpatentcourt localdivisionmunich Local division - Munich localdivisionmunich UPC_CFI_9/2023 UPC_CFI_9/2023 upccfi92023 upc_cfi_92023 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Patent pools 专利池 patentpools Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Provision of security 保证金提供 provisionofsecurity Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Proportionality 比例原则 proportionality FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Patent exhaustion 专利权穷竭 patentexhaustion Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Injunctions 禁令 injunctions FRAND defence FRAND 抗辩 franddefence
诺基亚科技诉OPPO手机英国有限公司及他人 诺基亚科技诉OPPO手机英国有限公司及他人 案号HP-2021-000022 案号HP-2021-000022 hp2021000022 hp-2021-000022 Worldwide (portfolio) licenses 全球范围（专利组合）许可 worldwideportfoliolicenses Jurisdiction for FRAND disputes FRAND相关案件的管辖权 jurisdictionforfranddisputes Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
通用电气（Access Advance）诉TCL 通用电气（Access Advance）诉TCL 案号21 O 4140/21 案号21 O 4140/21 21o414021 21o414021 Implementer’s reaction to offer 实施人对许可要约的回覆 implementersreactiontooffer Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Patent pools 专利池 patentpools Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Fulfilment of Huawei obligations in pending proceedings 在未决诉讼中对华为义务的履行 fulfilmentofhuaweiobligationsinpendingproceedings Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Injunctions 禁令 injunctions FRAND defence FRAND 抗辩 franddefence
21 O 5693/22 - LG 慕尼黑 21 O 5693/22 - LG 慕尼黑 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmunich 慕尼黑地区法院 regionalcourtlgmunich 21 O 5693/22 21 O 5693/22 21o569322 21o569322 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts Non-disclosure agreement 保密协议 nondisclosureagreement ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Fulfilment of Huawei obligations in pending proceedings 在未决诉讼中对华为义务的履行 fulfilmentofhuaweiobligationsinpendingproceedings Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Non-practising entity 非专利实施主体 nonpractisingentity Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Injunctions 禁令 injunctions FRAND defence FRAND 抗辩 franddefence
诺基亚诉OPPO英国英格兰及威尔士高等法院案 诺基亚诉OPPO英国英格兰及威尔士高等法院案 Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Nullam congue vulputate pede. Aenean sed erat at leo fringilla pharetra. Duis consequat rutrum felis. Suspendisse vestibulum. Vivamus libero leo, mollis vitae, tempus at, posuere id, lacus. Sed dapibus ornare nisi. Vivamus justo augue, viverra ac, semper id, commodo sed, eros. Aenean porta. Donec porttitor, massa sit amet consectetuer auctor, enim odio tristique nibh, vel ultrices enim risus quis justo. Donec tincidunt elementum dolor. Phasellus lectus. Ut sit amet urna. 英国 all unitedkingdom englandandwaleshighcourtofjustice 英格兰和威尔士高等法院 englandandwaleshighcourtofjustice [2023] EWHC 1912(Pat) [2023] EWHC 1912(Pat) 2023ewhc1912pat 2023ewhc1912pat Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Worldwide (portfolio) licenses 全球范围（专利组合）许可 worldwideportfoliolicenses Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Cross-licensing 交叉许可 crosslicensing Technical and FRAND-related trials 技术性及与FRAND相关的审判 technicalandfrandrelatedtrials Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Patent validity 专利有效性 patentvalidity FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Patent infringement 专利侵权 patentinfringement Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
飞利浦(Philips) v TCT 飞利浦Philips v TCT 2 U 13/21 2 U 13/21 2u1321 2u1321
Optis v Apple Optis v Apple 21 O 11522/21 21 O 11522/21 21o1152221 21o1152221
Optis诉苹果案 Optis诉苹果案 英国 all unitedkingdom englandandwaleshighcourtofjustice 英格兰和威尔士高等法院 englandandwaleshighcourtofjustice [2023] EWHC 1095 (Ch) [2023] EWHC 1095 (Ch) 2023ewhc1095ch 2023ewhc1095ch Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Worldwide (portfolio) licenses 全球范围（专利组合）许可 worldwideportfoliolicenses Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Damages 损害赔偿 damages ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Country by country licensing 个别国家/地区许可 countrybycountrylicensing SSPPU 最小可销售专利实施单元 ssppu Hold-up 专利挟持 holdup Technical and FRAND-related trials 技术性及与FRAND相关的审判 technicalandfrandrelatedtrials Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Patent validity 专利有效性 patentvalidity FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Patent exhaustion 专利权穷竭 patentexhaustion Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Over-declaration 过度声明 overdeclaration Top-down method 自上而下方法 topdownmethod Patent infringement 专利侵权 patentinfringement Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
慕尼黑地方法院O 13016/21案 慕尼黑地方法院O 13016/21案 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmunich 慕尼黑地区法院 regionalcourtlgmunich SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Relevant market 相关市场 relevantmarket Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Fulfilment of Huawei obligations in pending proceedings 在未决诉讼中对华为义务的履行 fulfilmentofhuaweiobligationsinpendingproceedings Anti-suit injunction 禁诉令 antisuitinjunction Anti-anti-suit injunction 反禁诉令 antiantisuitinjunction Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation Injunctions 禁令 injunctions FRAND defence FRAND 抗辩 franddefence
诺基亚vs Oppo 诺基亚vs Oppo 德国法院判决 all germany higherregionalcourtolgkarlsruhe OLG Karlsruhe higherregionalcourtolgkarlsruhe 6 U 212/22 6 U 212/22 6u21222 6u21222 Implementer’s reaction to offer 实施人对许可要约的回覆 implementersreactiontooffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Damages 损害赔偿 damages Cross-licensing 交叉许可 crosslicensing Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Non-practising entity 非专利实施主体 nonpractisingentity Patent infringement 专利侵权 patentinfringement Injunctions 禁令 injunctions Alternative Dispute Resolution 替代性争议解决 alternativedisputeresolution FRAND defence FRAND 抗辩 franddefence
Optis v Apple Optis v Apple 英国 all unitedkingdom ukcourtofappeal 英国上诉法院 ukcourtofappeal [2022] EWCA Civ 1411 [2022] EWCA Civ 1411 2022ewcaciv1411 2022ewcaciv1411 Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Damages 损害赔偿 damages ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Country by country licensing 个别国家/地区许可 countrybycountrylicensing Hold-up 专利挟持 holdup Technical and FRAND-related trials 技术性及与FRAND相关的审判 technicalandfrandrelatedtrials Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Patent validity 专利有效性 patentvalidity FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Patent infringement 专利侵权 patentinfringement Injunctions 禁令 injunctions Alternative Dispute Resolution 替代性争议解决 alternativedisputeresolution Arbitration 仲裁 arbitration FRAND defence FRAND 抗辩 franddefence
诺基亚诉OPPO案 诺基亚诉OPPO案 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmunich 慕尼黑地区法院 regionalcourtlgmunich 21 O 11522/21 21 O 11522/21 21o1152221 21o1152221 SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Implementer’s reaction to offer 实施人对许可要约的回覆 implementersreactiontooffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Worldwide (portfolio) licenses 全球范围（专利组合）许可 worldwideportfoliolicenses Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Proportionality 比例原则 proportionality Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Non-practising entity 非专利实施主体 nonpractisingentity Patent infringement 专利侵权 patentinfringement Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
诺基亚诉OPPO案 诺基亚诉OPPO案 英国 all unitedkingdom ukcourtofappeal 英国上诉法院 ukcourtofappeal [2022] EWCA Civ 947 [2022] EWCA Civ 947 2022ewcaciv947 2022ewcaciv947 Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Worldwide (portfolio) licenses 全球范围（专利组合）许可 worldwideportfoliolicenses Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Cross-licensing 交叉许可 crosslicensing Hold-up 专利挟持 holdup Technical and FRAND-related trials 技术性及与FRAND相关的审判 technicalandfrandrelatedtrials Patent validity 专利有效性 patentvalidity Jurisdiction for FRAND disputes FRAND相关案件的管辖权 jurisdictionforfranddisputes FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Patent infringement 专利侵权 patentinfringement
IP Bridge v TCT IP Bridge v TCT 德国法院判决 all germany higherregionalcourtolgkarlsruhe OLG Karlsruhe higherregionalcourtolgkarlsruhe 6 U 149/20 6 U 149/20 6u14920 6u14920 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Royalty stacking 权利金堆叠 royaltystacking Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Adjustment clause 调整条款 adjustmentclause Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation Top-down method 自上而下方法 topdownmethod Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
IP Bridge v HTC IP Bridge v HTC 6 U 104/18 6 U 104/18 6u10418 6u10418 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Implementer’s reaction to offer 实施人对许可要约的回覆 implementersreactiontooffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Damages 损害赔偿 damages Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Royalty stacking 权利金堆叠 royaltystacking Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Patent validity 专利有效性 patentvalidity Fulfilment of Huawei obligations in pending proceedings 在未决诉讼中对华为义务的履行 fulfilmentofhuaweiobligationsinpendingproceedings FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Patent exhaustion 专利权穷竭 patentexhaustion Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Adjustment clause 调整条款 adjustmentclause Covenant not to sue 不起诉协议 covenantnottosue Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation Patent ambush 专利埋伏 patentambush Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
Conversant诉华为 Conversant诉华为 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgdsseldorf Regional Court - LG Düsseldorf regionalcourtlgdsseldorf 4b O 30/18 4b O 30/18 4bo3018 4bo3018 SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Confidentiality 机密信息 confidentiality Non-disclosure agreement 保密协议 nondisclosureagreement ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Cross-licensing 交叉许可 crosslicensing Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Adjustment clause 调整条款 adjustmentclause Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Non-practising entity 非专利实施主体 nonpractisingentity Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
InterDigital诉小米 InterDigital诉小米 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmunich 慕尼黑地区法院 regionalcourtlgmunich 7 O 14276/20 7 O 14276/20 7o1427620 7o1427620 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Anti-suit injunction 禁诉令 antisuitinjunction Anti-anti-suit injunction 反禁诉令 antiantisuitinjunction Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence
LG诉TCL，曼海姆地区法院(Landgericht) LG诉TCL曼海姆地区法院Landgericht 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmannheim 曼海姆地区法院 regionalcourtlgmannheim 2 O 131/19 2 O 131/19 2o13119 2o13119 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Patent exhaustion 专利权穷竭 patentexhaustion Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
VoiceAge诉HMD案 VoiceAge诉HMD案 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmunich 慕尼黑地区法院 regionalcourtlgmunich 7 O 15350/19 7 O 15350/19 7o1535019 7o1535019 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts Non-disclosure agreement 保密协议 nondisclosureagreement FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Provision of security 保证金提供 provisionofsecurity Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Fulfilment of Huawei obligations in pending proceedings 在未决诉讼中对华为义务的履行 fulfilmentofhuaweiobligationsinpendingproceedings Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Non-practising entity 非专利实施主体 nonpractisingentity Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
IP Bridge诉华为 IP Bridge诉华为 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmunich 慕尼黑地区法院 regionalcourtlgmunich 7 O 36/21 7 O 36/21 7o3621 7o3621 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement Worldwide (portfolio) licenses 全球范围（专利组合）许可 worldwideportfoliolicenses Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Anti-suit injunction 禁诉令 antisuitinjunction Anti-anti-suit injunction 反禁诉令 antiantisuitinjunction Preliminary injunction 临时禁令 preliminaryinjunction Jurisdiction for FRAND disputes FRAND相关案件的管辖权 jurisdictionforfranddisputes FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation Non-practising entity 非专利实施主体 nonpractisingentity Worldwide (portfolio) licences Worldwide (portfolio) licences worldwideportfoliolicences
西斯维尔诉海尔 西斯维尔诉海尔 德国法院判决 all germany federalcourtofjusticebgh 德国联邦法院 federalcourtofjusticebgh KZR 35/17 KZR 35/17 kzr3517 kzr3517 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Implementer’s reaction to offer 实施人对许可要约的回覆 implementersreactiontooffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Worldwide (portfolio) licenses 全球范围（专利组合）许可 worldwideportfoliolicenses Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Damages 损害赔偿 damages Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange Relevant market 相关市场 relevantmarket ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Country by country licensing 个别国家/地区许可 countrybycountrylicensing Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Patent validity 专利有效性 patentvalidity Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Worldwide (portfolio) licences Worldwide (portfolio) licences worldwideportfoliolicences Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
诺基亚诉戴姆勒，卡尔斯鲁厄高级地方法院 诺基亚诉戴姆勒卡尔斯鲁厄高级地方法院 德国法院判决 all germany higherregionalcourtolgkarlsruhe OLG Karlsruhe higherregionalcourtolgkarlsruhe 6 U 130/20 6 U 130/20 6u13020 6u13020 SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Fulfilment of Huawei obligations in pending proceedings 在未决诉讼中对华为义务的履行 fulfilmentofhuaweiobligationsinpendingproceedings FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence Royalty calculation 许可费计算 royaltycalculation Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
Conversant诉戴姆勒案，慕尼黑第一地区法院（Landgericht München I） Conversant诉戴姆勒案慕尼黑第一地区法院（Landgericht München I） 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmunich 慕尼黑地区法院 regionalcourtlgmunich 21 O 11384/19 21 O 11384/19 21o1138419 21o1138419 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Implementer’s reaction to offer 实施人对许可要约的回覆 implementersreactiontooffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Worldwide (portfolio) licenses 全球范围（专利组合）许可 worldwideportfoliolicenses Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Damages 损害赔偿 damages Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange Relevant market 相关市场 relevantmarket ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Country by country licensing 个别国家/地区许可 countrybycountrylicensing Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Provision of security 保证金提供 provisionofsecurity Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Proportionality 比例原则 proportionality Fulfilment of Huawei obligations in pending proceedings 在未决诉讼中对华为义务的履行 fulfilmentofhuaweiobligationsinpendingproceedings Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment License to all v Access to all 所有潜在实施人均有权直接要求被许可 v. 所有潜在实施人均有权取得许可 licensetoallvaccesstoall Over-declaration 过度声明 overdeclaration Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
夏普诉戴姆勒 夏普诉戴姆勒 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmunich 慕尼黑地区法院 regionalcourtlgmunich 7 O 8818/19 7 O 8818/19 7o881819 7o881819 SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Patent pools 专利池 patentpools Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Patent exhaustion 专利权穷竭 patentexhaustion Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
诺基亚诉戴姆勒 诺基亚诉戴姆勒 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmannheim 曼海姆地区法院 regionalcourtlgmannheim 2 O 34/19 2 O 34/19 2o3419 2o3419 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Patent pools 专利池 patentpools Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Damages 损害赔偿 damages Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange Relevant market 相关市场 relevantmarket ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination SSPPU 最小可销售专利实施单元 ssppu Hold-up 专利挟持 holdup Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Patent exhaustion 专利权穷竭 patentexhaustion Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
西斯维尔诉Wiko 西斯维尔诉Wiko 德国法院判决 all germany regionalcourtlgmannheim 曼海姆地区法院 regionalcourtlgmannheim 7 O 115/16 7 O 115/16 7o11516 7o11516 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Patent pools 专利池 patentpools Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts Confidentiality 机密信息 confidentiality Non-disclosure agreement 保密协议 nondisclosureagreement FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Provision of security 保证金提供 provisionofsecurity Fulfilment of Huawei obligations in pending proceedings 在未决诉讼中对华为义务的履行 fulfilmentofhuaweiobligationsinpendingproceedings FRAND determination FRAND判定 franddetermination Patent exhaustion 专利权穷竭 patentexhaustion
大陆集团诉诺基亚 大陆集团诉诺基亚 德国法院判决 all germany higherregionalcourtolgmunich 慕尼黑高级地区法院 higherregionalcourtolgmunich 6 U 5042/19 6 U 5042/19 6u504219 6u504219 Anti-suit injunction 禁诉令 antisuitinjunction Anti-anti-suit injunction 反禁诉令 antiantisuitinjunction Preliminary injunction 临时禁令 preliminaryinjunction Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
西斯维尔诉海尔 西斯维尔诉海尔 德国法院判决 all germany federalcourtofjusticebgh 德国联邦法院 federalcourtofjusticebgh KZR 36/17 KZR 36/17 kzr3617 kzr3617 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Worldwide (portfolio) licenses 全球范围（专利组合）许可 worldwideportfoliolicenses Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Portfolio licensing 專利组合许可 portfoliolicensing Huawei obligations 华为的义务 huaweiobligations Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Damages 损害赔偿 damages Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts FRAND range FRAND范围 frandrange Relevant market 相关市场 relevantmarket ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Worldwide (portfolio) licences Worldwide (portfolio) licences worldwideportfoliolicences Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
IPCom诉联想 IPCom诉联想 法国法院判决 all france courtofappealofparis Court of Appeal of Paris courtofappealofparis 14/2020 14/2020 142020 142020 Anti-suit injunction 禁诉令 antisuitinjunction Anti-anti-suit injunction 反禁诉令 antiantisuitinjunction
飞利浦诉华硕 飞利浦诉华硕 荷兰法院判决 all netherlands thehaguecourtofappeal The Hague Court of Appeal thehaguecourtofappeal 200.221.250/01 200.221.250/01 20022125001 200.221.25001 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Comparable agreements 可比协议 comparableagreements Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Claim charts 权利要求对照表 claimcharts Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Implementer’s counter-offer 实施人的许可反要约 implementerscounteroffer Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Patent validity 专利有效性 patentvalidity Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Injunctions 禁令 injunctions
华为诉中兴通信 华为诉中兴通信 判决主页 all cjeudecisions C-170/13 C-170/13 c17013 c-17013 Notification of infringement 侵权通知 notificationofinfringement SEP owner’s offer 标准必要专利持有人许可要约 sepownersoffer Implementer’s reaction to offer 实施人对许可要约的回覆 implementersreactiontooffer Hold-out 反向专利挟持 holdout Essentiality 标准必要性 essentiality Recognised commercial practice 既有商业惯例 recognisedcommercialpractice Huawei framework 华为框架 huaweiframework Abuse of market power 滥用市场支配力 abuseofmarketpower Damages 损害赔偿 damages Recall of products 产品召回 recallofproducts Rendering of accounts 开立担保帐户 renderingofaccounts ETSI declaration ETSI承诺 etsideclaration Non-discrimination 无歧视 nondiscrimination Hold-up 专利挟持 holdup Provision of security 保证金提供 provisionofsecurity Antitrust 反垄断 antitrust Patent validity 专利有效性 patentvalidity Willingness to obtain a licence 取得许可的意愿 willingnesstoobtainalicence FRAND commitment FRAND许可承诺 frandcommitment Injunctions 禁令 injunctions